Introduction to Estate Litigation

3 Minute Read

Estate litigation covers a wide variety of legal disputes that can arise regarding the administration and settling of a deceased person’s estate. Let’s discuss below.


Unlike other areas of law, proceedings in estate litigation are often conducted by way of Application rather than Action (a trial). Although, some proceedings by application can lead to an action depending on the nature of the claims.

Proceedings by applications can be less contentious than actions, and the average application process can usually take 6 – 8 months or sometimes more depending on the complexity of the case.


Here are the most common matters that can lead to estate litigation:

WILL CHALLENGES

These claims intend to invalidate a Will so that it can no longer guide the administration of an estate. The most common grounds for challenging the validity of a Will include improper execution, fraud or forgery, lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence and suspicious circumstances, revocation or supersession, disinheritance claims, and legal formalities of a Will.

WILL INTERPRETATION CASES

These claims intend to seek Court intervention to help clarify the meaning and intent of a Will when there are ambiguities, uncertainties, and disputes regarding the internal language and provisions. Learn more about the different types of claims that can made against Wills below:


FIDUCIARY DUTY CLAIMS

These claims are made against fiduciaries who have breached their fiduciary duties. A fiduciary refers to an individual who manages an estate or trust, or acts as a substitute decision-maker for someone else, such as estate trustees or executors, trustees (of a trust), an attorney under a power of attorney, and guardians (of the person or property). Learn more about these claims below.


SUPPORT CLAIMS MADE AGAINST AN ESTATE

These claims are made by individuals who were dependent on the deceased immediately before death to seek financial support from the deceased’s estate if they were inadequately provided for within the provisions of the deceased’s Will.


APPLICATION TO PASS ACCOUNTS

Any individual who is a fiduciary is responsible for keeping accurate and complete financial records of any decisions they make, any assets they manage, and any payments they make. An application to pass accounts refers to the legal process of obtaining the Court’s approval of account records made by a fiduciary. The fiduciary typically makes an application to pass their accounts.


SERVICES RENDERED & QUANTUM MERUIT CLAIMS

Services rendered claims are made by service providers to seek payment for services they have provided to the service receiver when the agreed-upon fees for the service are not paid in full. If the service rendered was provided to a deceased individual, these claims are made against their estates to recover unpaid fees.

Quantum meruit claims are made by service providers to seek fair and reasonable compensation for the services they have provided to the recipient party, in situations where there is no explicit contract or agreement between the service provider and the service recipient. The claims may also be recovered from a deceased individual estate.


The lawyers at Sweatman Law have over 30 years of experience in estate litigation. Contact us here to get in touch!

RELATED ARTICLES

DISCLAIMER: This blog post should not be interpreted as legal advice for your specific situation, concerns, or challenges. All litigation matters are unique and should be reviewed by legal, financial, and health professionals, and tax accountants. Please be advised that the information on this website relates to laws specific to Ontario or Canadian federal law. Legal advice, procedure, and legislature may vary in different jurisdictions.

WOULD YOU LIKE QUICK AND INFORMATIVE ANSWERS TO YOUR BURNING QUESTIONS?

Available now on our website, our FAQs page can answer your questions about:

  • Guardianship
  • Estate Planning
  • Wills, Powers of Attorney, Trusts
  • Estate Litigation
  • Dispute Resolution
  • Probate & Estate Administration
  • MAiD

Related Posts

Checklist: Executor’s Duties

This checklist provides a general overview of executor’s duties designed to assist the estate trustee in dealing with the complexities of estate administration. √ Initial Work The executor’s first steps are to make funeral/burial arrangements, obtain the Funeral Director’s Proof of Death and the deceased’s identification, bank and credit cards, collect the Last Will, any

Read More »

Estate Trustee Compensation

An estate trustee is entitled to fair and reasonable compensation for performing his or her duties. The compensation or fees due to an estate trustee is usually calculated on the basis of receipts which come into the trustee’s hands and then disbursed to creditors and beneficiaries. Usually the fee is not increased if there is

Read More »

Estate Information Return

What are the consequences for NOT filing with the Minister of Finance? Estate representatives who fail to file the Information Return as required, or who make false or misleading statements on the return, are guilty of an offence and, on conviction, are liable to a fine of at least $1,000 and up to twice the

Read More »

Estate Administration Basics

When a person dies the property he or she holds in their own name, whether real or personal, is called an estate. A Will is a legal document that names the person or persons appointed as estate trustee (formerly an executor/executrix) and sets out the scheme of distribution of the assets. It also provides the

Read More »

Dealing With Digital Assets in an Estate

Due to the pervasiveness of the internet and modern technology, most Canadians are leaving behind a “virtual estate” after death. A “virtual estate” is all the deceased’s digital assets left behind, including electronic possessions such as financial information, songs, tweets, photos and social media. A digital asset is a file or record that one has

Read More »

Community Resources for Seniors

What is a Care Home? A care home is rented accommodation that provides care services. Such services include nursing care, prescription drug supervision, an emergency response system, transportation, incontinence care and assistance with daily activities (e.g., eating, bathing, dressing, and personal hygiene). If you live in a care home, you have the same rights as

Read More »
Scroll to Top